Table of content
Thanks to blockchain technology, this means of organizing became possible on scale and convenience unseen before. DAOs often have more transparent governance, which makes them more efficient than traditional associations.
In this article, we’re going to talk about about more about DAO’s essence, highlight its strengths and weaknesses, the way they function, and the legal aspects of launching and operating them.
What is DAO definition and how do they operate?
Decentralized Autonomous Organizations are organizations whose governance format is determined on the level of smart-contract.
Usually, decisions in DAOs are made by voting. The subject and the format of voting can vary. For example, making one decision will require the consent of a simple majority, whereas others can demand the overwhelming majority consent. It can also be the simple majority members participating in a given poll, the “liquid democracy” system, and many other variations.
Voting power in DAOs is allocated via the so-called Governance Coin. Governance coin is DAO’s crypto token that serves an administrative purpose. The more tokens a member possesses, the more voting right this person has.
A DAO may also set the rules concerning what may be put to the vote, as well as determine the voting procedure. DAO can vote to make amendments to its smart contract or deploy the organization’s financial resources stored on it. Some voting results are enacted automatically on the blockchain level, such as funds transfer, but voting can concern any matter of the organization’s life. All in all, there is an infinite number of formats for DAO operations and governance depending on its goals.
What can DAOs be created for?
DAOs can represent an organization of any type. It can be a large corporation or a small non-profit. It can even be a school’s parent committee or inhabitants of the same multiapartment building, collaborating on the day-to-day issues.
The most recent example of how the decentralized autonomous organization can work was the Constitution DAO ― a group of people who chipped in to buy one of the USA constitution first versions. The goal they had in mind was to demonstrate that the items of historical heritage must not only belong to the elites but be in the hands of the nation. An agenda like this is a typical example of the DAO use case.
Profit distribution in DAOs
The following practical DAO aspect is the division of profits inside the organization, which is relevant for the for-profit DAOs. The most basic approach is accumulating profits in the smart contract and periodically dividing on a pro-rata basis among the holders of the governance token, similarly to how dividends work.
Another possible option is doing buybacks of the governance token. This raises the price of the governance token by reducing its supply, therefore being an indirect way to distribute dividends. A pattern like this may be beneficial if capital gains taxes are lower than income taxes.
An interesting variation of the buyback option can be implemented if the governance token also serves as the utility token of DAO. If the DAO collects fees only in this token, the profits will be accumulated in its native token. Therefore, it can burn the token instead of distributing it. This is similar to the buyback option as this also reduces the circulating supply.
Interestingly, while the two previous options are similar to the ones implemented by traditional corporations, the third one is unique to DAOs. It’s beneficial compared to conventional buybacks because tokens are taken out of circulation immediately when the DAO receives any revenue. This is equivalent to distributing corporate revenue as dividends immediately after each small portion of income has been received.
The further development of the given technologies would probably be the best if stablecoins and CBDCs came hand in hand. However, in practice, it is noticeable that stablecoins meet some obstacles in their development, while the CBDC usage is constantly being enforced. As for today, many countries’ authorities state that cryptocurrencies can’t be legal tender, meaning they cannot be legal payment methods: those can be only governmentally issued currencies, including CBDC. Because of this, it won’t be easy to reach global stablecoins adoption, and the mainstream users who will learn to interact with crypto will accordingly be able to use this skill in other crypto applications. This factor gives a hint that CBDCs are likely to displace stablecoins.
One more factor worth noting is that governments also tend to regulate stablecoins in a rigorous way. Some usual requirements include registering them as securities or obtaining a bank license, any of which actually only makes stablecoin issuance more difficult and vulnerable to different lawsuits. Due to this, the government will likely be using its power to pressure the stablecoins issuers so that CBDCs will be more widespread.
Legal Side of the Moon
Let’s talk about DAO’s legal personality. Usually, decentralized autonomous organizations don’t have legal entities at all. Still, regulators in various countries are starting to move toward giving them a chance to be a legal person. For example, DAOs can now be recognized as a special type of LLC in Wyoming. At the moment of writing this article, we are not aware of such options in other countries.
DAO could benefit from having a legal entity to be able to sign contracts with counterparties. Even though in the crypto industry, many interactions work purely based on trust and smart contracts, more broad adoption of DAOs requires engaging in more formal legal relationships.
An organization set up like DAO still has to deal with lease contracts, open bank accounts, pay salaries, and so on, which is where the legal personality comes in handy. A drawback of having a legal entity is that it creates additional challenges and expenses on its administration, reporting, setup, etc. This is why early-stage DAOs may not benefit from launching it.
The second essential aspect is the regulation of the governance token. There are two things to consider:
In some countries, all cryptocurrency issuers, including DAO, must register. For instance, in the US, all the issuers controlling the emission and burn of crypto assets are considered money service businesses. Accordingly, they have to register under the Bank Secrecy Act in each State separately, except for the few that don’t require such registration. For this reason, many ICOs and exchanges don’t work with US residents at all.
The securities legislation. Sometimes, the governance tokens can be recognized as securities, often providing voting rights and profit distribution to their holders. The crucial metric distinguishing a DAO token and a security token is whether the token in question offers a right to obtain profit and the way it is distributed. There’s also a factor of whether the token is promoted as an investment with an expectation of generating returns.
Different countries have different regulations and criteria for determining whether the token is security: for example, the Howey test in the US is stricter compared to other jurisdictions. Being classified as a financial instrument doesn’t render the governance token obsolete but creates a limitation on its promotion and registration or notification requirements, the violation of which may result in harsh consequences. To stay secured, it’s better to get advice from lawyers or consultants specializing in the field.
DAO: Hits and Misses
Decentralized autonomous organizations possess 3 benefits over traditional ones.
Pro: Better decision-making process
During decentralized decision-making, more people contribute their expertise and perspective, resulting in a broader picture compared to centralized decision-making.
Pro: Increased member engagement
People enjoy participating in activities where they feel a sense of belonging and their ideas are heard; given that in DAOs, their input is more likely to make a difference, members are more likely to be active contributors to the DAO’s life.
Pro: Fairer to members and stakeholders
It makes sense to have a say in an organization you invested in instead of being dependent on the will of centralized management.
Now let’s switch to misses.
Con: Vulnerable on the smart contract level
which can be used for voting manipulation. For this reason, it’s crucial to conduct a quality security audit.
Some decisions can’t be implemented on the smart contract level
For example, it’s possible to block money withdrawal from the smart contract by voting but not from the bank account. This also refers to a myriad of day-to-day operations and decisions. Unfortunately, it leaves space for some measure of abuse. This is why DAOs should create a system of checks and balances, as well as a sufficiently sophisticated governance system.
Vulnerable to the decline in member participation
The strong side of DAOs is the devotion and contribution of members, but if they burn out, the organization weakens. Respectively, DAOs should constantly rejuvenate and reenergize the member’s base, build the community, attract new members, and engage existing ones.
Successful Cases of DAO Implementation
Metaverse: Decentraland
A pioneer in Metaverse, Decentraland is a 3D digital world run entirely by its members. Apart from having a chance to do different things enabled by metaverse’s mechanics, Decentralandians can make decision if they hold MANA, its crypto token.
Fighting Climate Change: Klima
Klima DAO leverages blockchain technology to combat climate change. It uses tokenomics to create demand for carbon credits, encouraging industries to offset their emissions. Members govern the DAO’s strategy to increase transparency and accountability in carbon trading markets.
Making Education Available: EduDAO
EduDAO connects universities and students globally to manage research funding collaboratively. Members decide which projects to support, promoting interdisciplinary collaboration and fair access to resources. This DAO fosters innovation in education through decentralized governance.
Final word
New technologies are well compared to philosophy as a concept: it’s only useful while it makes human life clearer and easier. In this extent, blockchain has made a great job, demonstrating a lot of different means of helping people, delivering humanitarian value and simply making life easier. DAO business model, for one, helps communities stay consolidated and boosts each memeber’s sense of belonging, not to mention an excellent way to fundraise.
If you’d like to launch your own DAO, define decentralized organization you’d like to create or experience the possibilities of Web3 on a more detailed level and how can it help your business, contact Devox. We provide a range of tech-related services for blockchain startups, as well as consult business owners on how can blockchain help deliver your promise.
